History
and Evolution of the DEMO Study
In
the 1980s, public concern over the fate of the northern spotted
owl and the loss and fragmentation of the old-growth forests
on which it depends led to unprecedented interest in natural
resource management in the Pacific Northwest. Fueled by intense
political activism, local and regional debates gained national
prominence
as lawsuits initiated by environmental groups led to a series
of injunctions from federal district courts that brought timber
sales to a halt on lands managed by the Forest Service and
Bureau of Land Management. In April 1993, in response to this
"timber crisis," President Clinton commissioned
the Forest Ecosystem Management Assessment Team (FEMAT) to
formulate and assess the consequences of an array of options
for managing federal forest lands within the range of the
northern spotted owl. This assessment was the first attempt
to develop a comprehensive plan for ecosystem management at
a broad geographic scale. The Record of Decision, and the
standards and guidelines associated with the resulting management
plan, The Northwest
Forest Plan, were published in April 1994. Green-tree
or structural retention is now a standard component of harvest
prescriptions on federal "matrix" lands within the
range of the northern spotted owl.
As changes
in federal forest management policy evolved under the paradigm of "ecosystem
management," it became apparent that implementation of new approaches
to management was hampered by a paucity of research, and in particular,
research targeted to and integrated with management. To address these
needs, an Ecosystem Management Partnership (subsequently named New Perspectives
Partners) was formed, bringing together scientists from the University
of Washington, Oregon State University, the UDSA Forest Service Pacific
Northwest Research Station, and the Aerial Forest Management Foundation,
and resource managers from the USDA Forest Service Pacific Northwest Region.
Working
with members of Congress in 1992, the partners emphasized the need for
experiments on alternative approaches to forest harvest and suggested
how such studies might be implemented on federal and state lands in the
Pacific Northwest. At the same time, the Douglas Project Coalition (a
local group of businessmen and citizens from Douglas County, Oregon) sought
funds for a large-scale study and demonstration of the biological, social,
and economic consequences of diverse management strategies. In 1992 Congress
allocated funds to support the establishment of silvicultural experiments
in Washington and Oregon using "new forestry" and "landscape
management techniques." The Forest Service was directed to conduct
this work in consultation with the New Perspectives Partners and Douglas
County Coalition. After considerable debate on research objectives, management
needs, and experiments, a final experimental design was adopted - one
that tested a broad range of retention levels (15
to 100%) and two distinct spatial patterns of retention (dispersed vs.
aggregated). From a larger
group of potential study locations in western Oregon
and Washington, eight
blocks were identified, each containing relatively homogenous stands large
enough to support six, 13-ha experimental units.
For a detailed
treatment of the evolution and history of the DEMO study see:
Franklin,
J.F., L.A. Norris, D.R. Berg, and G.R. Smith, 1999. The history of DEMO:
An experiment in regeneration harvest of northwestern forest ecosystems.
Northwest Science 73 (Special Issue): 3-11.
|